Prioritizing Donor Retention in Your Fundraising Strategy
Retaining donors is more cost-effective than acquiring new ones. Learn practical strategies nonprofits can use to improve donor retention and grow sustainably.
For many nonprofits, planned giving is a critical source of funding that ensures long-term sustainability. However, the traditional approach of presenting a planned gift as a donation or gift can sometimes fall short of resonating with donors who want to make a lasting impact. To elevate the conversation around planned giving, nonprofits can reposition it not merely as a charitable gift, but as an investment in the organization’s long-term mission.
By shifting this perspective, nonprofits can engage donors who want to feel like active partners in securing a future for the causes they care about most.
When donors include a nonprofit in their estate plans, they’re making a profound commitment to that organization’s long-term success. Planned gifts, such as bequests, charitable trusts, and annuities, provide financial stability that can help nonprofits weather economic uncertainties and continue their mission-driven work.
While one-time donations are vital for immediate needs, planned gifts create a sustainable financial foundation. This is what sets planned giving apart—it’s not just a gift for today, but an investment in tomorrow.
To effectively position planned giving as an investment, nonprofits should reshape the “ask” narrative. Instead of focusing solely on the donor’s generosity, emphasize how their planned gift will serve as an enduring investment in the nonprofit’s future. This approach appeals to individuals who want to see their contributions make a measurable and lasting difference.
Key messaging might include:
Once the concept of planned giving as an investment is established, nonprofits should adapt their outreach strategies to engage potential donors. Some effective ways to do this include:
By positioning planned giving as an investment, nonprofits can engage a broader spectrum of donors who are interested in securing the long-term viability of the causes they support. Framing these gifts as an enduring contribution to the nonprofit’s mission will not only deepen donor engagement but also build a sustainable foundation for future growth.
Nonprofits that embrace this mindset shift will find that their planned giving strategies can grow significantly, ensuring that their mission continues to thrive for years to come. For more information about how LifeLegacy can support your planned giving goals.
Head of Partnerships
Craig@lifelegacy.io
Retaining donors is more cost-effective than acquiring new ones. Learn practical strategies nonprofits can use to improve donor retention and grow sustainably.
If you need a single, compelling reason to prioritize planned giving this year, here it is: around 46 billion dollars flows to charities every year through bequests. In fact, the latest Giving USA numbers show that bequests in 2024 totaled about $45.84 billion—roughly 8% of all U.S. charitable giving for the year. That’s not a rounding error; it’s a transformative funding stream your mission can’t afford to ignore.
One of the most interesting parts of planned giving is that you never know what is going to happen! Planned gifts will surprise you. In an earlier blog, I talked about the planned gift that I DIDN’T accept. That was not even close to the most interesting gift that I ever received.
And this one isn’t either. But it was something I never expected.
Be the first to get notified when we go live with our will product.